The H&H Verdelho 20 Year was easily WOTN. This wine was $100 at Schneider's and now I'm curious to try it vs some young vintage products: only '85 & '86 D'Oliveira and '92 Barbieto play in the same price class (+/- 25% ($75-125)). Not shown is a 1968 Blandy Verdelho that we tried it against at the end - the '68 was simply in another league.
The H&H Terrantez 20 Year also deserves special mention. Delicious, not amazing, doesn't compare to the 70's Terrantez that I've had and I don't yet have the '88 'D'Oliveira in my possession which is the only vintage bottle in the price class - the '77 D'Oliveira starts at $160.
The RWC bottles are all enjoyable beverages but none stood out as a type favorite to any of the 3 of us present (good pallets all but all Madeira amateurs). So far the RWC Jefferson is easily my favorite from the collection (I recently bought a case - that's how much I like it) and I I look forward to trying the Porto Moniz and Stratford Hall bottles that I have en route.
Sorry for the dark photo. Our order was L to R, bottles marked ## were already open -everything else was basically pop/pour:
- RWC Baltimore Rainwater
- RWC Savannah Verdelho
- H&H Verdelho 20 Year
- H&H Terrantez 20 Year
- RWC Mr Madison (primarily 2006 Malmsey, with a small amount of very old Tinta Negra )
- RWC New York Malmsey
- Broadbent 10 Year Malmsey ##
- H&H 10 Year Malmsey ##
- H&H 15 Year Malmsey ##
- Bland 15 Year Malmsey
