I'm just curious to get the opinions or maybe the real reason behind this.
Why some producer are using Tawny 10 Year Old while others Tawny 10 YearS old. Are both valid or one better than the other?
Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
Moderators: Glenn E., Roy Hersh, Andy Velebil
-
- Posts: 2710
- Joined: Sun Jul 31, 2005 10:07 am
- Location: Porto, Portugal
Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
Living the dream and now working for a Port company
-
- Posts: 1271
- Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2006 7:38 pm
- Location: Montréal Canada
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
I think it comes down to proper syntax
A 10 year old tawny sounds better
A 10 year old tawny sounds better
Vintage avant jeunesse/or the other way around . . .
- Glenn E.
- Posts: 8176
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 10:49 am
- Location: Sammamish, Washington, United States of America - USA
- Contact:
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
I suspect it is basically a translation error, or perhaps more correctly differences in languages.
In Portuguese, the category is "10 anos" which is plural. "10 Years" is the literal translation.
But in English, that doesn't really make sense so we have to change it to 10 year old, or 10 years old, either of which is a legitimate expression of what the Portuguese means.
To me, it looks and sounds more correct to use the singular on the label. That is essentially saying "this is a 10 year old tawny Port." (Nevermind that that's not what the category means; that's a different discussion.) To use the plural one would need to re-arrange the sentence to "this tawny Port is 10 years old" and that just looks and sounds weird.
But perhaps more importantly, I suspect that one or the other is required by law in various markets, so seeing both probably just means you're seeing bottles intended for different markets.
In Portuguese, the category is "10 anos" which is plural. "10 Years" is the literal translation.
But in English, that doesn't really make sense so we have to change it to 10 year old, or 10 years old, either of which is a legitimate expression of what the Portuguese means.
To me, it looks and sounds more correct to use the singular on the label. That is essentially saying "this is a 10 year old tawny Port." (Nevermind that that's not what the category means; that's a different discussion.) To use the plural one would need to re-arrange the sentence to "this tawny Port is 10 years old" and that just looks and sounds weird.
But perhaps more importantly, I suspect that one or the other is required by law in various markets, so seeing both probably just means you're seeing bottles intended for different markets.
Glenn Elliott
-
- Posts: 1271
- Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2006 7:38 pm
- Location: Montréal Canada
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
Would you say :
Glenn has aged while tasting a 10 year old tawny
Or
An aged Glenn has tasted 10 year old tawnys
Glenn has aged while tasting a 10 year old tawny
Or
An aged Glenn has tasted 10 year old tawnys
Vintage avant jeunesse/or the other way around . . .
- Andy Velebil
- Posts: 16627
- Joined: Tue Aug 02, 2005 4:49 pm
- Location: Los Angeles, California, United States of America - USA
- Contact:
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
Depends on how far along he is in his tasting.Luc Gauthier wrote: ↑Wed May 19, 2021 11:35 am Would you say :
Glenn has aged while tasting a 10 year old tawny
Or
An aged Glenn has tasted 10 year old tawnys
Andy Velebil Good wine is a good familiar creature if it be well used. William Shakespeare http://www.fortheloveofport.com
- Glenn E.
- Posts: 8176
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 10:49 am
- Location: Sammamish, Washington, United States of America - USA
- Contact:
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
It takes me a while to drink an entire bottle of Port, you know!Andy Velebil wrote: ↑Wed May 19, 2021 12:52 pmDepends on how far along he is in his tasting.Luc Gauthier wrote: ↑Wed May 19, 2021 11:35 am Would you say :
Glenn has aged while tasting a 10 year old tawny
Or
An aged Glenn has tasted 10 year old tawnys
Glenn Elliott
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
It's usually a "Tawny, 10 years old" or "10 year old Tawny", i.e. The choice depends whether the word Tawny comes before or after the age. Of course, potentially someone from marketing then gets involved without sufficiently explicit instruction and in designing the label everything gets moved around...
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
(also not forgetting other options which allow the above ordering to be broken, e.g. "Port, 10 years old, Tawny" etc)
-
- Posts: 994
- Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 7:55 pm
- Location: In the middle of cornfields & cow pastures, PA
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
Personally, I haven't aged in 10 years.Luc Gauthier wrote: ↑Wed May 19, 2021 11:35 am Would you say :
Glenn has aged while tasting a 10 year old tawny
Or
An aged Glenn has tasted 10 year old tawnys
"I have often thought that the aim of Port is to give you a good and durable hangover, so that during the next day you should be reminded of the splendid occasion the night before." - Hungarian/British journalist & author George Mikes
-
- Posts: 6340
- Joined: Wed Sep 24, 2008 9:48 pm
- Location: Longmont, Colorado, United States of America - USA
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
And at the risk of starting a tangent, one can find on commercial labels Grahams, Graham's, and Grahams'.
- Andy Velebil
- Posts: 16627
- Joined: Tue Aug 02, 2005 4:49 pm
- Location: Los Angeles, California, United States of America - USA
- Contact:
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
You just had to go there didn’t you hahaEric Menchen wrote:And at the risk of starting a tangent, one can find on commercial labels Grahams, Graham's, and Grahams'.
Andy Velebil Good wine is a good familiar creature if it be well used. William Shakespeare http://www.fortheloveofport.com
- Glenn E.
- Posts: 8176
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 10:49 am
- Location: Sammamish, Washington, United States of America - USA
- Contact:
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
Is that Vintage With An Indication of Grammar?Eric Menchen wrote: ↑Wed May 19, 2021 10:35 pm And at the risk of starting a tangent, one can find on commercial labels Grahams, Graham's, and Grahams'.
Glenn Elliott
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
Honestly, I love this. Too much in our lives is over-thought, manipulated, on a unified "message" etc. The fact that there are great oddities is charming and honest and another reason to LOVE Port....just my two cents.
Any Port in a storm!
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
Decidedly going off on a tangent, what is the plural form of tawny?
-
- Posts: 1271
- Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2006 7:38 pm
- Location: Montréal Canada
- Glenn E.
- Posts: 8176
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 10:49 am
- Location: Sammamish, Washington, United States of America - USA
- Contact:
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
A tawny port; many tawny ports.Al B. wrote:Decidedly going off on a tangent, what is the plural form of tawny?
A tawny; many tawnies.
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
Also if it was Graham drinking the tawnies instead of Glenn, we might be looking at Graham's Graham's, Graham's Grahams and Graham's Grahams' tawnies. If Graham also had a friend tasting with him and his friend's name was also Graham, or perhaps Mr John Graham named his son Graham, and his son also named his son Graham, and the son and grandson met to drink, then we could have Graham Graham's Graham's, Grahams and Grahams', and Grahams' Graham's, Grahams and Grahams' tawnies. I need a lie down now.
-
- Posts: 994
- Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 7:55 pm
- Location: In the middle of cornfields & cow pastures, PA
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
That reminds me of the classic Monty Python skit:Phil W wrote: ↑Fri Jun 04, 2021 12:56 am Also if it was Graham drinking the tawnies instead of Glenn, we might be looking at Graham's Graham's, Graham's Grahams and Graham's Grahams' tawnies. If Graham also had a friend tasting with him and his friend's name was also Graham, or perhaps Mr John Graham named his son Graham, and his son also named his son Graham, and the son and grandson met to drink, then we could have Graham Graham's Graham's, Grahams and Grahams', and Grahams' Graham's, Grahams and Grahams' tawnies. I need a lie down now.
"Customer:
Morning
Waitress:
Morning
Customer:
What have you got?
Waitress:
Well, there's egg and bacon
Egg sausage and bacon
Egg and spam
Egg, bacon and spam
Egg, bacon, sausage and spam
Spam, bacon, sausage and spam
Spam, egg, spam, spam, bacon and spam
Spam, sausage, spam, spam, spam, bacon, spam tomato and spam
Spam, spam, spam, egg and spam
Spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, baked beans, spam, spam, spam and spam..."
"I have often thought that the aim of Port is to give you a good and durable hangover, so that during the next day you should be reminded of the splendid occasion the night before." - Hungarian/British journalist & author George Mikes
Re: Aged Tawny, Year or Years?
The port equivalent would perhaps require a team of us to hold a Graham's vertical, at the Graham's Lodge, while wearing viking helmets and singing "port, port, port, port" whenever anyone orders a glass or asks about the tastings. Silly walks to and from the toilets obligatory.