IMO there is no point of planning on the forum the next VT 2 weeks ahead...
Derek, I don't want to get too general. The basic idea of the VT is to get different point of view on a very specific topic to help port lover making better decision based on their own taste. So if we open the VT to any Ruby or Tawny, we'll loose that aspect as the topic is too general and we won't be able to compare others taste for similar product.
We've had a run of top quality products in the recent VT, I think it is time now to get back to simpler products or a Port house tasting.
Here's what I would suggest, either to taste a Port from Smith Wooshouse(inspired by Roy's new post) or take a wide sample at a 10yo tawny. Any thoughts?
Living the dream and now working for a Port company
Apologies if I jumped in too early in starting this thread. I was merely surprised by the lack of participation in the April tasting and wanted to explore ideas that might bring more people into the idea of a VT. However, I fully accept your desire to keep the VTs focused and not let the theme become too wide that it lacks cohesion.
I think your suggestions are good but I would say that the 10 yr old tawny would be more accessable to more people that a Smith Woodhouse theme.
I have a SW Madalena 1988 and a Taylor 10 yr old Tawny on standby awaiting your decision
As ultimately this is Frederick Blais' VT Forum, he has the final say. I like the idea of picking a producer, as long as it is one that is widely available to a large majority of FTLOPers. I think that Smith woodhouse fits into that category. However, I will shut up from here and let Frederick make up his own mind. :help:
It is not my show, just the idea I started out. I really do like to hear what people like or not and I'm open to suggestion too, like Derek did. In the end I'll make the final choice, but based on what people have to say. If I make a choice that is not based on that, the participation rate will not be good. So please tell me if you have any good ideas, suggestion that could make drinking and sharing port more enjoyable for enthousiast and buyers.
Living the dream and now working for a Port company
Don't worry we are in total agreement. I was not saying you are the "dictator" here. Getting feedback and opening it up to other opinions is always a wise way to go. But ultimately, someone has to make a final decision and long ago you were empowered with that privilege. You have done it was great aplomb. Thanks!
Everything currently in my collection that is 22+ years old is a Colheita!
