Re: What have you opened this week?
Posted: Thu Dec 11, 2014 11:15 pm
Last night decanted a 1986 Graham's VP for the weekend..
Forum for Port, Madeira & Portuguese Wines
https://www.fortheloveofport.com/ftlopforum/
https://www.fortheloveofport.com/ftlopforum/viewtopic.php?t=11459
I'm more interesting in if you got any V.A. in it, as that is a pretty known problem in this vintage.Allan Engelsted Laurents wrote:Hi Eric
It seems to me that You like the 375 sized bottles? Does the 97 Niepoort in the smaller edition, not have the same cork problem, as the bigger brother?
I tend to awoid buying Ni 97 just for that same reason. But Maby I should look for the halved sized bottle.
Best regards
Allan
The last two bottles I opened were 750s, but I do like the 375s for just sharing with my wife. I've heard about the problems with the 750s and was also wondering if the 375s were o.k. I haven't heard a definitive answer, and this bottle didn't resolve things either. TN posted. I didn't get VA on the first night, but as I finish it off two days later I think it is there.Allan Engelsted Laurents wrote:Hi Eric
It seems to me that You like the 375 sized bottles? Does the 97 Niepoort in the smaller edition, not have the same cork problem, as the bigger brother?
I think I'll pull mine out and start drinking them. No reason to have them taking up space if they're not sound.Eric Menchen wrote:The last two bottles I opened were 750s, but I do like the 375s for just sharing with my wife. I've heard about the problems with the 750s and was also wondering if the 375s were o.k. I haven't heard a definitive answer, and this bottle didn't resolve things either. TN posted. I didn't get VA on the first night, but as I finish it off two days later I think it is there.Allan Engelsted Laurents wrote:Hi Eric
It seems to me that You like the 375 sized bottles? Does the 97 Niepoort in the smaller edition, not have the same cork problem, as the bigger brother?
Hrm... yet more disturbing news about Ni97. I bought a 6-pack a while back and when I heard about the VA problems I opened one. It was terrific, so I hoped that my batch would be good ones. But this is really starting to sound like a very consistent problem... maybe I should open another one to check. The Niepoorts (and Broadbent, which is bottled by Niepoort) at the 1994 retrospective were all pretty riddled with VA.Andy Velebil wrote:I think I'll pull mine out and start drinking them. No reason to have them taking up space if they're not sound.Eric Menchen wrote:The last two bottles I opened were 750s, but I do like the 375s for just sharing with my wife. I've heard about the problems with the 750s and was also wondering if the 375s were o.k. I haven't heard a definitive answer, and this bottle didn't resolve things either. TN posted. I didn't get VA on the first night, but as I finish it off two days later I think it is there.Allan Engelsted Laurents wrote:Hi Eric
It seems to me that You like the 375 sized bottles? Does the 97 Niepoort in the smaller edition, not have the same cork problem, as the bigger brother?
1985 through 1997, though 1985 (at least in my experience) doesn't seem to be nearly as bad as 1994 and 1997. 2000 seems to have solved the problem, and I've not really experienced any problems prior to 1985 though others might have.John M. wrote:Is it just me, or are there several years with problems with VA/TCA for Niepoort VPs? Seem to recall 85 & 94, too.
What VA was there was not significant, and I didn't notice it at first. On the flip side, VA doesn't bother me like a lot of people, and I drink a lot of funky beers. So I'm not writing these bottles off so easily, and still considering bidding on the 375s in the Zachy's auction.Andy Velebil wrote:I think I'll pull mine out and start drinking them. No reason to have them taking up space if they're not sound.Eric Menchen wrote:I didn't get VA on the first night, but as I finish it off two days later I think it is there.