Event: Comparing 1987 Graham LBV vs. 1987 Graham Malvedos Vintage
Posted: Sat Nov 27, 2010 9:44 am
Got this old LBV from a Portuguese friend abt 5 yrs ago, and thought it would be interesting to taste it together with the Malvedos vintage of same year. Although it is not clearly said on the reverse label, I got the impression that the LBV is also from Malvedos.
Evaluated the two bottles immediately after opening, and gave the LBV 87 pts and Malvedos vintage 89 pts. Then they were both decanted for abt 6 hours. The LBV had then fallen to 85 pts, while the Malvedos had improved to 91 pts. Very interesting exercise.
1987 Graham LBV (0.75 l)
Bottled 1993. As much sediments as the vintage of same year. Bottle was unfortunately somewhat oxidized, but not so much that it prevented me from judging the port. Metal capsule and the cork had no signs of leakage. Medium dark red colour. Aroma of old cellar, burnt sugar and something candied. Medium body, balanced, a lot of tannins, not showing much spirit, long finish. After the decanting the tannins were less dominant. 85 pts.
1987 Graham Malvedos Vintage (0.375 l)
Bottled 1989. Dark purple colour. Aroma dominated by wood and spirit (much less spirit after decanting) with fruit less noteable. Medium body, elegant, nice tannins (less than the LBV). Short to medium finish. Quite a nice vintage, confirming that 1987 is a very good “off-year”. 91 pts
Evaluated the two bottles immediately after opening, and gave the LBV 87 pts and Malvedos vintage 89 pts. Then they were both decanted for abt 6 hours. The LBV had then fallen to 85 pts, while the Malvedos had improved to 91 pts. Very interesting exercise.
1987 Graham LBV (0.75 l)
Bottled 1993. As much sediments as the vintage of same year. Bottle was unfortunately somewhat oxidized, but not so much that it prevented me from judging the port. Metal capsule and the cork had no signs of leakage. Medium dark red colour. Aroma of old cellar, burnt sugar and something candied. Medium body, balanced, a lot of tannins, not showing much spirit, long finish. After the decanting the tannins were less dominant. 85 pts.
1987 Graham Malvedos Vintage (0.375 l)
Bottled 1989. Dark purple colour. Aroma dominated by wood and spirit (much less spirit after decanting) with fruit less noteable. Medium body, elegant, nice tannins (less than the LBV). Short to medium finish. Quite a nice vintage, confirming that 1987 is a very good “off-year”. 91 pts