Page 1 of 1

Who would YOU buy?

Posted: Thu Oct 11, 2007 10:19 pm
by Todd Pettinger
Co-related to Fred's post on who is taking up the most space in your cellar, as far as Port goes, if you had a reasonable amount of money to stock up (let's say around $25,000 or the equivalent in your currency) to spend ONLY on Port, which producers would you stock up on? You can include the "why" but I suspect for everyone it would be a similar response: I like <this brand> of Port and would obviously stock up on the one I like the most. ;)

I would have:
Taylor
Fonseca
Noval
Graham's

I would probably also try and stock up on some Niepoorts, but it is hard to make that call, given I have not yet had the opportunity to try ANY of his offerings.

Ok, dream away folks!
Todd

Posted: Thu Oct 11, 2007 11:02 pm
by Erik Wiechers
Haaaaaaaa, excellent question.
25.000 would be 17.600 euro

hmmm, i think i would buy a case of 1963 Noval Nacional, if they still exist outthere.
Store it away, lock myself up in the cellar, throw away the key and look at it all day :D

Posted: Thu Oct 11, 2007 11:07 pm
by Todd Pettinger
Would that even buy a case of '63 NN Erik??? Only wine-searcher hit I could come up with, listed it at $3250 and change for one bottle :shock: times 12 and you're looking at $39,000.

So aside from that non-existent case of Nacional, what else would you choose?!? ;)

Posted: Thu Oct 11, 2007 11:40 pm
by Jay Powers
If restricted to only one producer, I would go Grahams, with a focus on 63, 66 (my favorite), 70, 85, 94, and 2000.

With that much money in one bolus of port buying, I would mix it up with some Noval Nacional (63 and 94), some 1937 Colheitas, and some older port (1927/31/34/45/55).

Some to drink now, and some to drink later! I would not restrict myself to a single producer, and would buy some "odd lots" to try as well.

Jay

Posted: Thu Oct 11, 2007 11:45 pm
by Erik Wiechers
I was hoping for a 6 bottle case :)

But i would definately buy the older vintages, like 1945 Niepoort, 1970 Fonseca or a really really OLD bottle, like a 1820 Ferreira Garrafeira Port (cost € 1450).

To own a piece of history is also part of the fun for me.

Posted: Fri Oct 12, 2007 2:49 am
by João Rico
Noval Nacional
Noval
Niepoort
Dow
Fonseca
Taylor´s

Posted: Fri Oct 12, 2007 6:34 am
by Frederick Blais
With unlimited money.... I'd just travel the world to find any of those rare 19th century bottles to have a chance to taste them once.

The Ferreira 250th celebration special box with very old bottles. There is still one at the Vintage House.

And of course a couple of cases of all vintages of Nacional, old colheita of Niepoort... and a house on the banks of the Douro ... with a glass to taste this :o