Quinta do Crasto ... comparing 2005 and 2006

[Roy Hersh]

What is your opinion of the quality of the 2005 vs. 2006 basic Douro red wine? Do you have a preference? Rating?

As the 2006 Vinha Velha Douro is not yet available for sale, what is your opinion about the 2005?

[Frederick Blais]

I don't know if it was bottle variation or just wine changing with time but I had the best and the average with the Vinha Velha 2005. I did have the opportunity to drink their 2006s yet. From 2005 my most memorable souvenir was the Touriga Nacional, they really make it spot on!

[Roy Hersh]

Don't forget the very special 2005 Maria Teresa either. Others have opinions on these wines?

[Frederick Blais]

Don't forget the very special 2005 Maria Teresa either.

I did taste it, but wasn't blasted. I really liked the elegance of the TN. For me the Teresa is a bit too much of everything without the right balance. We'll see how it will age, hopefully it will turn great.

[Roy Hersh]

I had this a year and a half ago the first time and as a cask sample on 3 different occasions. Additionally, as I have now had this a half dozen times since this April in Vancouver (from finished bottles) I think the MT'05 epitomizes balance. Please do try it again when you have a chance and I'd love to read your updated opinion.